Skip to main content

Card Art Evolution: Forest Troll

UPDATE: Since this article was written, Deck of Wonders launched on Kickstarter, funded in less than 2 days, and is now racing through stretch goals! You can check the Kickstarter page out here, and I've added the full, final art for Forest Troll in all it's glory to the end of this article. Enjoy, and you can check out a bunch more final card art here!

I've taken a very iterative approach to developing Deck of Wonders, and card art has been no different! Below is the journey of one card's art over the course of development so far. Forest Troll is one of my favorite cards in the game, and its art (at all stages) has become a kind of avatar for Deck of Wonders. I'm sure it will evolve even further before the game is released (e.g. the card template is obviously still in development), but it's really fun to look at how it's evolved over time! Let me know your thoughts on where Forest Troll and the card template should go from here, and let me know if you'd like to see this kind of overview for any other cards!

I do all my prototyping with a normal deck of playing cards, and a reference sheet in Excel indicating which playing card is what. 9s were the original card that represented Forest Troll, and I had originally given them 4 health instead of 3. That changed in the first couple of games when I lost every time and failed to kill even a single Villain Forest Troll.

When I decided to preview my game at Gen Con, I knew playing cards wouldn't cut it, so I mocked up a wireframe prototype using shapes in Powerpoint. At that point my idea for the layout was that the card would stay oriented the same direction no matter what, although it quickly became clear in practice that people would rather orient the card to have the active side "up".

I didn't have time or money to commission art for every card, so I chose to leave art off of the original cards entirely. I had the idea of a mirrored image with slight differences by side (almost like a spot-the-difference game), and I wanted to be able to communicate that to people as I was demoing, so I asked Elsa Furia to mock up a few pieces of card art, and put those in the rulebook that came with the prototype. Forest Troll was one of 3 pieces of art she put together for me in a "children's book" style, and I love all the subtle differences between the two!

When my success at Gen Con proved I was on to something with Deck of Wonders (I'm still amazed that so many people bought an art-fee wireframe prototype), I knew I'd need art for every card if I wanted to get a better prototype together. I needed to stick with super-rough, black and white sketches to reasonably afford the volume of art, so Elsa gave Forest Troll a make-under to fit in with the other cards, including the idea to have him be more animalistic. This was a directional sketch she did on the way to the final "v2" prototype art.

After a round or two of refinement, we settled on this design, telling the two-panel story of the Forest Troll seeing the player and then launching a boulder at them. This version was sold at CinCityCon and is still in use in the Tabletop Simulator version of the game.

A big insight from CinCityCon was just how overtly the cards needed to communicate their "good" vs "evil" side. It's not a change to the art, but the dark vs light change to the template went a long way to reduce confusion. This version of the template made it into the PNP version of the game.

Between physical and PNP sales of the v2 prototype, I raised enough to commission final art for Deck of Wonders! I met Lauren Brown at Gen Con, and her style was instantly locked into my mind as the right look for the game. She took the animalistic look of Forest Troll to the next level, while weaving back in some of the "spot the difference" type ideas that were in the very first version of the card art.

Cleaning up the roughs into line art didn't bring too many other changes. It was at this point that we had the idea that the Forest Troll might change colors with the season or with their emotion, but it was hard to know how that would work before color.

Turns out it works GREAT!!! I fell instantly in love with the color version of Forest Troll, and while the template will continue to evolve, I can't imagine how the card art could be any more perfect.
UPDATE: Here is the full, final card art in-template!

Check out more of Elsa's art here.
Check out more of Lauren's art here.
Click here to back Deck of Wonders on Kickstarter!


Popular posts from this blog

Board Game Equity Pyramid

As I've gotten into game design, I've found many of the tools from my "day job" in brand strategy super helpful. I recently put out a poll to the game design community asking what brand strategy topics might be useful to them, and overwhelmingly the #1 request was for help clearly communicating the equity of a game to others. I mashed up a couple of brand strategy tools through the specific lens of board game design, and this is the result! You can get a blank template for yourself right here . Fill it out (either for the board game you're designing, or for an existing game as practice) and post your results here. I geek out about this kind of marketing stuff, and would love to deconstruct it with you! What about the template is most useful? What's not useful? What's missing? Click here  to back Deck of Wonders on Kickstarter!

How to Play Videos for Deck of Wonders

For those who prefer watching to reading, here's a quick rules overview for how to play Deck of Wonders! I'll add more videos to this as I'm able.

ALL the Art Reveals!

We've gone on an art-revealing rampage over the past couple of weeks! Check out these interviews with our friends across the board game universe to see several new cards and hear the stories behind them: Sleep - Dice & Dragons Pixie Cleric - Tabletop Rebellion Ent Hermit - Better Half Reviews Attack Wasp - Board Game Rundown Vengeful Spirit - One Stop Co-op Shop We'll update this post as more new art is revealed, and can't wait to get ALL the art into your hands when the game ships is February 2022! Click here  to late pledge to Deck of Wonders!